diff --git a/src/autoreplace_gui.cpp b/src/autoreplace_gui.cpp
--- a/src/autoreplace_gui.cpp
+++ b/src/autoreplace_gui.cpp
@@ -375,8 +375,15 @@ public:
 				break;
 
 			case WID_RV_TRAIN_WAGONREMOVE_TOGGLE: {
-				const Company *c = Company::Get(_local_company);
-				SetDParam(0, c->settings.renew_keep_length ? STR_CONFIG_SETTING_ON : STR_CONFIG_SETTING_OFF);
+				bool remove_wagon;
+				const Group *g = Group::GetIfValid(this->sel_group);
+				if (g != nullptr) {
+					remove_wagon = HasBit(g->flags, GroupFlags::GF_REPLACE_WAGON_REMOVAL);
+				} else {
+					const Company *c = Company::Get(_local_company);
+					remove_wagon = c->settings.renew_keep_length;
+				}
+				SetDParam(0, remove_wagon ? STR_CONFIG_SETTING_ON : STR_CONFIG_SETTING_OFF);
 				break;
 			}
 
@@ -528,9 +535,16 @@ public:
 				}
 				break;
 
-			case WID_RV_TRAIN_WAGONREMOVE_TOGGLE: // toggle renew_keep_length
-				DoCommandP(0, GetCompanySettingIndex("company.renew_keep_length"), Company::Get(_local_company)->settings.renew_keep_length ? 0 : 1, CMD_CHANGE_COMPANY_SETTING);
+			case WID_RV_TRAIN_WAGONREMOVE_TOGGLE: {
+				const Group *g = Group::GetIfValid(this->sel_group);
+				if (g != nullptr) {
+					DoCommandP(0, this->sel_group | (GroupFlags::GF_REPLACE_WAGON_REMOVAL << 16), (HasBit(g->flags, GroupFlags::GF_REPLACE_WAGON_REMOVAL) ? 0 : 1) | (_ctrl_pressed << 1), CMD_SET_GROUP_FLAG);
+				} else {
+					// toggle renew_keep_length
+					DoCommandP(0, GetCompanySettingIndex("company.renew_keep_length"), Company::Get(_local_company)->settings.renew_keep_length ? 0 : 1, CMD_CHANGE_COMPANY_SETTING);
+				}
 				break;
+			}
 
 			case WID_RV_START_REPLACE: { // Start replacing
 				if (this->GetWidget<NWidgetLeaf>(widget)->ButtonHit(pt)) {